Income Volatility: Why It Destabilizes Families and How Philanthropy Can Make a Difference

Joanna Smith-Ramani

Co-Executive Director

Katherine Lucas McKay

Principal Researcher, Insights and Evidence

Traditionally, grantmakers have focused on workforce development and upskilling as part of economic mobility strategies for low-wage workers. However, as work has evolved and jobs look more different than ever, it is critical to understand the impact of these changes on income—predictability, variability, and frequency—and how this affects the opportunity for mobility.

This problem is not the same as income insufficiency, or simply the story of stagnating wages over the last few decades. These same workers are experiencing low-wages coupled with major week-to-week and month-to-month fluctuations in their income. When this volatility is combined with a general lack of upward mobility, the results are toxic: high-interest debt, unstable housing, and food insecurity, among other destabilizing effects. Income volatility combined with wage stagnation helps explain the precarious position many families find themselves in today.

And while volatility makes it harder to manage cash flows and can trigger demand for high-cost financial credit products, it also seems to have serious downstream effects on the health and education outcomes of children. Essentially, income volatility undermines every investment in education, public health, and economic development, chipping away at what would otherwise be positive returns.

This paper will help grantmakers understand the enormous challenge income volatility presents in our country and will present an array of strategies for philanthropy to leverage both investments and leadership to empower families to protect themselves from volatility’s worst effects. Drawing on 18 months of research, convenings, expert surveys, and stakeholder engagement, this brief identifies the constellation of the most promising solutions that need champions, resources, and acceleration. Because of the complexity of income volatility, there is a unique role for philanthropy to deploy not only investments, but also to leverage its influence and convening power.

A Financial Security Threat in the Courtroom
Publications

A Financial Security Threat in the Courtroom

For readers unfamiliar with the subject, we offer a simple, non-technical explanation of debt collection litigation.

Strong Foundations: Housing Security Solutions Framework
Publications

Strong Foundations: Housing Security Solutions Framework

Everyone can do something to expand housing security in their own communities. Find the robust set of solutions for effective, equitable, and sustainable housing in the full solutions framework.

The COVID-19 Eviction Crisis: an Estimated 30-40 Million People in America Are at Risk
Blog Posts

The COVID-19 Eviction Crisis: an Estimated 30-40 Million People in America Are at Risk

A look into how the eviction crisis caused by the global pandemic disproportionately affected predominantly Black and Latinx communities.

The True Cost of Caregiving
Publications

The True Cost of Caregiving

This report illustrates four pillars of care: child care and early education, adult and elder care, family caregiving and self care, and professional caregiving.

Building Financial Security in a COVID-19 World: Triage, Recover, Stabilize
Blog Posts Videos
Strong Foundations: Financial Security Starts with Affordable, Stable Housing
Publications

Strong Foundations: Financial Security Starts with Affordable, Stable Housing

This research brief explores how and why housing costs are a critical threat to Americans’ financial security.

Fines, Fees, and Financial Security in the US South
Blog Posts

Fines, Fees, and Financial Security in the US South

Toward a College-Debt-Free Society
Blog Posts

Toward a College-Debt-Free Society

This spring, the Expanding Prosperity Impact Collaborative (EPIC), an initiative of the Aspen Institute Financial Security Program, released a study on ways to help those with student loan debt to eliminate some portion of their federal student loans.

Highlights from EPIC’s First Expert Survey on Housing Affordability and Stability
Blog Posts

Highlights from EPIC’s First Expert Survey on Housing Affordability and Stability

In 2019, Aspen EPIC, an initiative of Aspen FSP, surveyed over 100 experts on housing affordability and stability.

housekeys
Blog Posts

A Glimpse into the Eviction Crisis: Why Housing Stability Deserves Greater Attention

Matthew Desmond’s Evicted exhibit shines an important light on the impact of eviction on families across the nation.