Expert Survey on Retirement Savings: Support for Solutions for an Inclusive, Adequate Retirement Savings System

Karen Biddle Andres

Director, Lifelong Saving and Investing

Tim Shaw

Director, Benefits Transformation Initiative and Senior Policy Advisor

In the report Re-Imagining Retirement Amid New Uncertainty 2020, Aspen FSP identified four priority design principles essential to creating a more robust, inclusive, and practical retirement savings ecosystem for people across America:

  1. Provide universal access to automatic enrollment in workplace retirement savings
  2. Help workers build liquid emergency savings alongside their retirement savings
  3. Make retirement savings portable
  4. Innovate to create lifetime income streams for everyone

Between December 2020 and March 2021, Aspen FSP conducted a survey to gauge levels of support – or lack thereof – among leaders across sectors for potential solutions to these priorities and other key challenges discussed over the past five years at the Aspen Leadership Forum on Retirement Savings.
Experts from Aspen Financial Security Program’s Retirement Savings email list and the Defined Contribution Institutional Investment Association (DCIIA) membership list were invited to participate in the survey. We received 182 total responses:

  • 100 experts from Aspen Institute Financial Security Program’s network participated
  • 82 experts from the membership of DCIIA participated
Key findings from our experts (by topic)

Ensuring Retirement Security for Everyone

Top priorities for addressing retirement security:

  • Expanding access to workplace retirement savings programs
  • Expanding access to automatic enrollment into retirement savings programs
  • Ensuring Social Security’s solvency

Access to Retirement Savings Programs

  • 77% of respondents support universal access to retirement accounts

Automatic Enrollment

  • 9 out of 10 experts believe a national retirement plan should feature automatic enrollment

Emergency Savings

  • Most respondents believe it is important for a national retirement plan to include an emergency savings feature

Automatic Portability

  • A majority of respondents support a government mandate for automatic portability

Lifetime Income

  • Nearly 2 out of 3 respondents support allowing some portion of retirement savings to be automatically converted into a guaranteed, regular stream of income in retirement

Racial Equity

  • Most experts surveyed believe the retirement savings system has contributed to the racial wealth gap between white households and BIPOC households in America, and indicate that addressing racial inequality is a major priority for their organization

For more information, download the complete report. If you’d like to connect further about the survey findings, please reach out to Sohrab Kohli: [email protected].

Lessons From Down Under: What Australia’s Retirement System Really Teaches Us About Trump Accounts and Social Security
Blog Posts

Lessons From Down Under: What Australia’s Retirement System Really Teaches Us About Trump Accounts and Social Security

Australia has become the go-to example for those arguing that America should rethink retirement. Here’s why that argument is incomplete.

Event attendees sit at tables speaking. In focus behind them, is a flipchart with notes about retirement savings advice.
Publications

The Future of Advice: Going from Fragmented Help to Person-Centered Guidance

Households need financial and retirement advice that is affordable and accessible. What will it take to achieve that goal?

A wideshot of a room with several tables and dozens of people, watching a presentation at the front of the room.
Blog Posts

Trump IRAs Are Coming. Let’s Make Them Work for Those Who Need Them Most.

President Trump has just signed an executive order designed to expand retirement savings access. Here’s what this news means for low-income savers.

Lab Notes: 2025 Workers’ Wealth Lab
Blog Posts

Lab Notes: 2025 Workers’ Wealth Lab

Leveraging a first-of-its-kind database, the Workers’ Wealth Lab uses retirement plan data to identify the tools and design features that can improve our retirement savings system. Read the report from the 2025 Lab.

What’s the Future of Retirement Savings? We Get to Choose
Publications

What’s the Future of Retirement Savings? We Get to Choose

Retirement is the ultimate financial report card—for individuals and for America. Learn how leaders are working to make the retirement savings system work for everyone.

A person writing notes on a piece of paper
Blog Posts

How Auto-Enrollment Could Help Trump Accounts Work For Everyone

  • John Scott
America’s Babies Are Now Retirement Investors—Now What?
Blog Posts

America’s Babies Are Now Retirement Investors—Now What?

Trump Accounts could offer an 18-year head start on saving for retirement. How do we ensure that they work for everyone?

three people sit at a table in discussion
Blog Posts

Long-Time Listener, First-Time Caller: Why KC Boas Is Honored to Join Aspen FSP

KC Boas will join Aspen FSP as the Retirement Savings Initiative Lead.

8 Priorities (and 4 Big Questions) for Making America’s Retirement Savings System Work for Everybody
Publications

8 Priorities (and 4 Big Questions) for Making America’s Retirement Savings System Work for Everybody

Read the rapporteur report from the 8th annual Aspen Leadership Forum on Retirement Savings.