Moving from Experimentation to the Mainstream: Policy Options to Automate Workplace Emergency Savings

Karen Biddle Andres

Director, Inclusive Saving and Investing

Tim Shaw

Director, Benefits Transformation Initiative and Senior Policy Advisor

Emergency savings were a particularly important lifeline for families during the economic crisis of COVID-19, with 73% of Americans reporting a reduction in their income during 2020. A recent survey conducted by the Aspen Financial Security Program, Morningstar, DCIIA, and NORC at the University of Chicago found that families who had emergency savings before the pandemic were much better able to maintain their financial health than those who did not. However, significant gaps in emergency savings by race and income were revealed, with a recent survey finding that 36% of Black and 28% of Hispanic workers reported having no emergency savings, compared to 24% of white households. Employers are starting to recognize the value of offering payroll deduction emergency savings tools to workers, and several different models are emerging. Today, these models face a variety of regulatory barriers to automatic enrollment, which limits the potential for automatic workplace emergency savings to reach scale. Fortunately, there are a variety of policy options available to policymakers to reduce or eliminate those barriers.In this brief we seek to illuminate policymakers’ opportunities to help make emergency savings both automatic and inclusive. The brief:  

  1. Explores the design features critical to a successful emergency savings tool;
  2. Provides an overview of workplace emergency savings innovation in practice;
  3. Summarizes the policy barriers preventing employers and providers from making workplace emergency savings automatic; and
  4. Offers a set of policy options that can make automatic emergency savings available to everyone.

The Aspen Institute Financial Security Program thanks the Blackrock Charitable Fund for its generous support of this brief. 

Wealth Building at Work: How Canary’s Emergency Relief Fund Helps Workers Maintain Assets and Avoid Debt
Publications

Wealth Building at Work: How Canary’s Emergency Relief Fund Helps Workers Maintain Assets and Avoid Debt

Aspen FSP partnered with Canary, a provider of employee emergency relief funds, to explore how workers used this workplace offering when faced with financial emergencies, as well as how it impacted their financial security and experiences at work.

How Workplace Emergency Savings Accounts Can Boost Employee Well-Being
Publications

How Workplace Emergency Savings Accounts Can Boost Employee Well-Being

Aspen FSP partnered with SecureSave, a provider of workplace emergency savings accounts (ESAs), to survey 274 SecureSave users about their financial well-being and catalyze a conversation around ESAs.

Leading with Empathy: Strengthening Benefits Delivery with Mike Wilkening
Blog Posts

Leading with Empathy: Strengthening Benefits Delivery with Mike Wilkening

Mike Wilkening’s work as a public servant has followed a simple philosophy: government in service of its people. In this blog, he shares more about his leadership approach and his position as an Aspen FSP Fellow.

A Persistent Challenge: How Financial Shocks Continue to Undermine Family Financial Security
Blog Posts

A Persistent Challenge: How Financial Shocks Continue to Undermine Family Financial Security

Most households experience at least one financial shock in a given year, but there are few comprehensive solutions to help them. How can we solve this persistent challenge?

Beyond Income: Worker Financial Security and the Role of Benefits Inside and Outside of the Workplace
Blog Posts

Beyond Income: Worker Financial Security and the Role of Benefits Inside and Outside of the Workplace

U.S. workers need access to both public and workplace benefits, but often the connections between these benefits are fractured.

Video: We Don’t Have to Choose Between Financial Stability and Wealth
Blog Posts Videos

Video: We Don’t Have to Choose Between Financial Stability and Wealth

Households need tools that help them afford everyday life and build long-term security. Too often, policy systems fail to respond to both of these needs and instead prioritize one goal over the other.

How Work and Savings Penalties Block Financial Security and Economic Mobility
Blog Posts

How Work and Savings Penalties Block Financial Security and Economic Mobility

Work and savings penalties prevent the economic mobility of millions of workers. Learn more about how employers are working to address these barriers.