It Starts with Purpose—Then What?

Judy Samuelson

Executive Director

In a recent gathering of executives with enterprise-level responsibilities for sustainability and social impact—terms that are being challenged in this moment of “recalibration” (a.k.a. uncertainty and upheaval)—the attendees posed this crucial question:

How do we sustain our ambition—and hold to our commitments—when market incentives are overturned, and business motivations face constant headwinds? Yes, it means articulating the value to the business, but what about the measure of the health of systems on which the company depends, but doesn’t control?

There is both uncertainty and opportunity at this moment.

How is business responding?

Anthropic stands out as an example of a company so clearly committed to principle, product safety and public trust that it said no to the Pentagon, refusing to break its rules on use of its products for mass surveillance of Americans or in support of fully autonomous weapons, and putting a major contract on the line.

What can we learn from this example?

Anthropic is winning at least this round of the fight. Microsoft, Google and others have filed friend-of-the-court briefs as the company challenges the government’s designation of the firm as a supply chain risk to national security.

Anthropic’s clear commitment to these rules of engagement along with its market reputation is winning market share. After OpenAI stepped into the breach at the Defense Department, uninstalls of its model ChatGPT spiked. Anthropic’s Claude, meanwhile, fought to keep up with demand, the site crashing as it contended with more than a million downloads a day.

To read about the founding of Anthropic feels like a fantasy. The first employees—siblings, no less—didn’t like the direction of Open AI and jumped ship to create a new entity, attracting more talent and eventually, capital, from those eager, or at least willing, to bet on the clarity of purpose and strong principles the company lives by.

It’s one thing to conceive of a better business model. But to enable and sustain that vision and commitment, as we are learning, takes something more.

Anthropic’s purpose and rules of engagement guide its thinking, but it’s the governance structure that enables the company to follow through.

The founders have adopted a corporate design—or governance model—to assure that the rules of engagement and public-purpose can, and will, outlast the tenure of the founders, who even in the best of circumstances can get waylaid by shareholders wielding influence, by executives tied to the stock price, and related short-term pressures that can put a company’s culture, reputation and future success at risk.

Could this be a turning point—one in which shareholder primacy actually bends to the public license to operate?

And Anthropic is not alone. This weekend I went deep into a less familiar example—at least to me—of clear rules of engagement, and protection of the company’s purpose.

Epic is the software company that created MyChart and a private enterprise that quietly, without the aid of venture capital or public markets, has become the de facto enabler of connectivity between medical records, digital payments, and the patient-doctor interface.

Founded in 1979 with less than $100,000 in seed capital, it took the company nearly 20 years to reach $50M in revenue. Decades later, the company is now viewed as integral to much of the medical ecosystem.

Founder Judy Faulkner is a software engineer with no formal business training. She may be the most successful female CEO ever by conventional measures, but has eschewed market conventions throughout her tenure to keep the corporate purpose at the center and assure the customer comes first.

Faulkner also controls 100% of the voting shares and has committed the company’s ownership to a “purpose trust” through a foundation when she dies. The Trust will be controlled 1/3 by her family, 1/3 by five long-term senior managers, and 1/3—wait for it—by three CEOs of EPIC’s most significant customers, including massive hospital systems that are locked into the one-architecture interoperability that Epic has built out, piece by piece, and now secures.

If you don’t know the story, or even if you think you do, I recommend the multi-hour podcast by Acquired. You will be both entertained and amazed.

The Trust will also be bound by the ten “commandments” or principles that underpin Epic’s culture and success, including Do Not Go Public, and a rule about building from within, no acquisitions allowed. It’s about preserving the architecture of the system. The rules of engagement and constraints like rejecting outside investors, keeps the customer at the center.

Welcome to Governance 2.0

The number of companies that have used a Trust to protect the firm from the push and pull of public markets and other outside pressures may not be growing rapidly, but the stories of those that do are meaningful. Consider Ikea, with its complex layers of ownership by a mix of foundations and companies, designed to preserve both independence and long-term thinking. Or Patagonia, whose founder has put the assets in a trust for the planet. Epic, and yes, Anthropic.

Walmart achieves some of the same protections through family ownership of a significant portion of shares. This structure, I believe, was critical in enabling Walmart’s most recent CEOs to establish new and important benchmarks on sustainability in procurement and to push expectations on energy use and packaging through its massive supply chain. It also enabled them to establish and hold to increases in wages and new investments in the workforce, despite market pressure to pull back.

Among the first to name this push-pull tension was Marjorie Kelly, author of The Divine Right of Capital: Dethroning the Corporate Aristocracy, which was published in 2001 at the time of Enron’s implosion.

“Ownership,” Marjorie wrote, “is the original systems condition.”

Eric Ries, entrepreneur and author of the bestselling The Lean Startup, is poised to build on this observation in his forthcoming book, Incorruptible: Why Good Companies Go Bad and How Great Companies Stay Great. He makes a critical point about governance to honor intentions and the future of the enterprise: that the ideal time to secure the future is before you have opened your doors.

Anthropic’s founders did just that, having learned their lesson the hard way.

I think Ries has written Incorruptible for founders and executives who already excel at mission and clarity of purpose, but—as the author’s case examples and stories illuminate—are still vulnerable to losing their way to forces that want to extract value today rather than build for the future. Eric’s solution? Design both ownership and governance to secure your enterprise beginning Day One, even if you are confident of your vision, path, and business model.

What might that mean for established firms facing challenges to their core purpose and mission?

At our gathering last week, our invited guest was Linda Hill of Harvard Business School. Linda shared insights from her new book, Genius at Scale. Written with co-authors Emily Tedards and Jason Wild, Genius at Scale profiles leaders who lift their sights from their own enterprise to the systems they depend on for future growth, but also influence or impact.

The book starts with Ajay Banga’s tenure as CEO of MasterCard and his belief that the future health of the enterprise required breaking the norms of the credit card industry to reach the unbanked. Mutual dependence. A new market, and new rules of engagement emerge and are respected.

Words like “co-creation” and “collaboration” start to make much more sense in the business world when the systems that enable both life and nature are at risk. Partners become essential. The skill sets needed to succeed—which Linda and her co-authors characterize as Architects, Bridgers and Catalysts—point us to mutually beneficial relationships, including B2B networks that become essential over time.

It’s a great read, and the road map is both inspiring and useful.

Are leaders ready to follow it?


This blog post was originally published on LinkedIn. Follow Judy Samuelson for more insights on business and society.