On December 30, Andrew Ross Sorkin dropped a post into Substack that muses about what he learned from writing his new book, 1929: Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History—and How it Shattered a Nation.
In addition to calling out parallels with our own gilded age, this part sticks with me:
“Some of the behavior that strikes us today as clearly immoral was, at the time, legal, normalized, and rarely interrogated. I tried repeatedly to find contemporaries who articulated objections in real time that feel obvious to us now—objections to practices we would consider indefensible. I couldn’t find them.”
Sorkin calls for humility in trying to judge history. But he also invites us to think about current behaviors in business that, while normal to us, may shock future historians. The one that rises to the top for me is how we compensate chief executives.
The system of executive compensation that we take for granted puts stock price at the center of pay. “Pay for performance” is considered best practice. For CEOs of public companies today, it’s not unusual for a pay package to include as much as 80–90% stock-based compensation, heavily outweighing salary and bonuses. Even CEOs who signed on to the Business Roundtable’s restatement of corporate purpose, with the intention to balance employee welfare, a healthy supply chain, and a sustainable business model, are tethered to the stock price.
Under the typical pay package, even if it is structured with a long-term payout, short-term pressures and perverse incentives to manage the stock price persist. The outsized stock rewards contribute to growing inequality, and in both public and private investor markets, “long-term” rarely exceeds 3–5 years.
It was not always this way. Until the 1980s, CEOs were paid a salary like most employees, plus bonuses tied to specific goals. The company came first, but chief executives took seriously their role in society—job creation, and until globalization disrupted these priorities, the welfare of the community.
The practice of paying executives in stock first emerged in the Silicon Valley as a no-cost way to attract talent. The practice began to spread to public markets in the 1980s, but the dam really broke in 1993, an unintended consequence of President Clinton’s $1 million cap on the deductibility of CEO pay. The arms race of paying executives in stock began in earnest, reinforced by everything from the single objective function taught in finance classrooms (“shareholder value”) to Say-on-Pay votes to ISS protocols that reinforce pay for performance.
But pay for what kind of performance?
Around 2010, in the wake of the financial meltdown, we were on the hunt for executives who would stand up on principle, recognize business and management of the corporation as a team sport, put fairness at the center of pay design, and realize the stock price as exogenous in the measure of real value.
I remember meeting with the CFO of a globally significant enterprise at the suggestion of one of the company’s Directors. The CEO had raised an objection to breaking the barrier of $20MM in his own pay. He thought it would call him out in a bad way and could set a precedent with unintended consequences. The Board disagreed, making the case that if they failed to send a market signal about his superior value to the enterprise, they would face questions about his competence or their confidence in his leadership.
This executive is no longer at the helm, and the company no longer exists. But answers to his quest to rein in pay remain elusive. An executive can’t do this alone. It requires collective action.
In 2020, the Aspen Institute Business & Society Program and Korn Ferry released five Modern Principles for Sensible and Effective Executive Pay in order to stimulate dialogue about compensation. There are no doubt other approaches that merit a closer look. The real challenge is to muster the courage within executive suites and Boardrooms to take the first step.
Where are we now?
The only time the executive’s pay is questioned by even a strong minority of the shareholders is when the stock price feels stuck. “Pay for performance” is alive and well—and is contributing mightily to the growth in inequality. This study by the RAND corporation captures the impact on workers of wage disparity over the decades.
We are in the thick of it now. 2025 was JP Morgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon’s most lucrative year ever. At roughly $770MM, his stratospheric pay combines salary, bonuses, dividends, stock grants, and appreciation of previously granted stock.
In commentary on Dimon’s pay, the NYT reported on his focus on “lifting regulations” that will enable more deal making. More deal making is undoubtedly good for JP Morgan and Jamie Dimon, but deregulation also has consequences and may shift risk to others. And what’s the measure of deals we prioritize? Do they create useful goods and services? Advances creative approaches to important problems, or employee welfare?
What have we missed about this moment?
I still believe that a tight circle of executives with concern for our collective future could change the course we are on. They could call “game over,” return to a more sensible stock allotment along with other performance measures, and reset the standards for how the chief executive is compensated.
Why should they? Because a system that leads to unsustainable levels of inequality and decreases social trust is not fit for the long term. And the future success of our economy depends on constructive collaboration between workers, firms, and the license to operate granted by the public.
A key to success is who convenes the first dinner party, and the circle they build from there. An agreement among the right 20 executives could change the conversation about CEO pay. They must be sitting executives who still have skin in the game.
I know who I would want at that table—executives who lead with confidence and a keen interest in the future. They would demonstrate concern for the overall economy by how they reward and invest in their own workforce, elevate innovations that are sustainable and respect the limits of natural resources. And yes, they will be paid handsomely to ensure their business model creates real value and avoids extracting value from employees or future generations.
Ironically, in this moment, it is Trump who questions norms like why we insist on quarterly, short-term, reporting, the role of proxy advisory firms, and stock buybacks. It might be a good time to ask other questions as well.
It’s time to rethink our assumptions on executive pay.
Judgment, Sorkin notes, is easy in hindsight. What is needed now is greater humility. We can see that we are on the precipice of something that will not resolve without a change in behavior.
Can we find our way?
This blog post was originally published on LinkedIn. Follow Judy Samuelson for more insights on business and society.