In the most recent release of Edelman’s research on trust, Richard Edelman writes:
“Last year, the Edelman Trust Barometer documented a descent into grievance, with 6 in 10 of our respondents telling us that they feel business and government actions harmed them, served the interests of only some…. Today, our mindset has pulled back from alarm and anger into the hard shell of insularity.”
The Edelman Trust Barometer finds as economic anxiety and tensions over technology and politics grow, people retreat to “familiar circles” that thwart broader connections.
But is there another way to look at what is possible from the safety of the “familiar”? When is leadership strengthened by building on close connections?
The response of the Minnesota business community, reacting publicly to the protests against ICE and killings on the streets of Minneapolis, could put a more positive spin on drawing inward. In fact, it could serve as a much-needed organizing principle for effective action.
A decades-long commitment by Minnesota companies to “place” has created both a remarkable legacy and cleared the path to the open letter released last week and now signed by more than 80 CEOs and corporations. Their city and state are under fire, and employees and customers have experienced unconscionable stress and tragedy. The statement called for de-escalation in the streets and offered a glimpse into a community of corporate executives and business owners with significant reach within the Twin Cities.
The executives’ statement is measured, and suggests a deep, and for some of us, reassuring level of business engagement and cross-sector collaboration. The signatories did not condemn the Trump administration or take a political stance. Yet the engagement of this business community likely was, and is, instrumental in changing the tone and, potentially, the tenor of federal intervention.
The day after the letter’s release, President Trump made gestures towards de-escalation—shuffling the command of ICE in Minneapolis and putting in place a chief of operations willing to admit mistakes and signal the need for a different playbook on the ground. Time will tell if the de-escalation is real.
The public letter was characterized in social media as “milquetoast” and weak because it didn’t excoriate ICE or the administration. But a joint statement by CEOs of major enterprises is still noteworthy as public statements by corporate leaders have become increasingly rare.
More importantly, the reference in the letter to weeks of direct engagement “behind the scenes” with public officials at all levels, to find a better path forward, is meaningful.
Isn’t that exactly what we want from local leaders?
When the connections between business and place are clear, virtually anything becomes possible. Minnesota is the poster child for proving this case, and business executives in the Twin Cities have had a lot of practice. What enabled this group to stand up when others have stepped back?
The Twin Cities and Minnesota benefit from one of the most visible, long-standing corporate commitments to their headquarters in the country. By the 1970s, a local standard of donating as much as 5% (the “Five Percent Club”) of pretax profits to community needs and institutions was already an established protocol. While the form evolves from just donations to other means of service, the level of support to critical needs and organizations still stands out. The local Chamber of Commerce elevates and enables these commitments as the Minnesota Keystone Program.
Yet, the public demands more from business today, calling out CEOs to stand up in defense of democracy, civil and human rights. Can the recent actions of these local leaders signal a way forward?
There is strength in community. Local connections are meaningful—and actionable. The CEOs within the Twin Cities and state of Minnesota are, indeed, a tight community—in the true sense of the word. What does and could that enable? What can we learn from this example of business leadership and engagement?
When we use the term “the business community” on the national scene, it’s more of a euphemism, or wish. Common concerns across the country tend to be about lower taxes, right-sizing regulations, and free trade.
These topics matter in Minnesota too, but the letter’s signatories share more immediate concerns about the health of their home and workforce. They seek employees ready to show up, who are less distracted by economic uncertainty, and at this moment, fear. In a locality like Minnesota, the connections are reinforced without getting on an airplane. The proverbial “come to the table” is real. A coffee shop can suffice.
And local investment makes business sense. The organizing principle and measure of success for local business leaders is the health of the neighborhoods, the quality of city services and education system, the readiness of the workforce and more. These factors align the interests of both HQ companies and local businesses who share customers, schools and real estate.
The signatories to the open letter released last week represent national and global brands, along with lower-profile local businesses. And they are experienced at dealing with crisis. The racially charged killing of George Floyd on May 25th, 2020 was catalytic for business leaders across the country, but it hit first and hardest at home. In Minneapolis.
To be credible, the Minnesota CEO statement also requires staying power. The need for a public statement became urgent after the shocking killings of Renée Good and Alex Pretti, but the work has only begun.
Dialogue and deep engagement will continue to be needed to align public and private interests. To make sustained progress on problems, from inequality to polarization, that contribute to growing distrust in both business and government, will require corporate leaders to deploy their influence, as well as investment dollars. For executives who are serious about being part of the solution, It will also mean taking a look at their own priorities and business model; to take a hard look at who receives the rewards and who carries the costs of business as usual.
Right now, for business, that means speaking out, as well as continuing to reach in.
This blog post was originally published on LinkedIn. Follow Judy Samuelson for more insights on business and society.